perhaps seperate voting is necessary... BUT.. and I MEAN BUT....
The main problem we have here is also people not rating songs based on true quality and content, and instead are basing voting on whether they like the style of the song...
The rating process is there to determine just that, how good is THIS SONG, not how much do I like progressive rock... or how little I like grunge.... There was already floated in another thread, and again in Swordfish's Bandamp Extra, the idea of splitting the rating into two parts, one for musical composition, and one for recording quality... this is also a good idea, because sometimes a great song gets a crappy rating because of crappy recording, because the person maybe can't afford anything but a $8 dynamic mic, and free software, and is too stupid to understand the dang full featured software like Cool Edit pro.(umm, hmm... that's not about me, it's about some hypothetical person, yeah, that's it)
Anyway, that said, I would like to see simplified BATTLE voting, and more indepth rating system... that would be good... all the way around... And there are certain songs that DONT belong in battles... that was the inspiration for my NOODLE KNIGHTS.. though, I feel bad, I am a bit behind in getting it updated... but soon.. I promise...
Jim "Da NOODLE KING" K
The main problem we have here is also people not rating songs based on true quality and content, and instead are basing voting on whether they like the style of the song...
The rating process is there to determine just that, how good is THIS SONG, not how much do I like progressive rock... or how little I like grunge.... There was already floated in another thread, and again in Swordfish's Bandamp Extra, the idea of splitting the rating into two parts, one for musical composition, and one for recording quality... this is also a good idea, because sometimes a great song gets a crappy rating because of crappy recording, because the person maybe can't afford anything but a $8 dynamic mic, and free software, and is too stupid to understand the dang full featured software like Cool Edit pro.(umm, hmm... that's not about me, it's about some hypothetical person, yeah, that's it)
Anyway, that said, I would like to see simplified BATTLE voting, and more indepth rating system... that would be good... all the way around... And there are certain songs that DONT belong in battles... that was the inspiration for my NOODLE KNIGHTS.. though, I feel bad, I am a bit behind in getting it updated... but soon.. I promise...
Jim "Da NOODLE KING" K
Sorry, you do not have access to post...
Wanna post? Join Today!